Six scenarios for a title: How the 2026 MLS Playoffs might transpire
Though 18 teams can technically win MLS Cup, realistic cases can be made for six of them — which, perhaps surprisingly, includes a pair of unusual No. 6 seeds.
Technically, 18 teams have a shot at winning MLS Cup in 2026, with the journey starting on Thursday for the four teams that squeaked into the play-in matches, and with others entering the fray on Saturday.
As I see it, six are mostly likely to triumph in the 2026 MLS playoffs, and curiously, Austin FC has played them all this season. MLS is truly a place where anything can happen in the playoffs — you'll recall that just two years ago, the Red Bulls emerged from the 7th spot in the East, with doubts late in that season that they'd even keep their long playoff appearance streak going, yet they found their way to the final.
To be fair, we have No. 6 seeds as two of our options — but they're highly unusual six-seeds.
Let's dig in.
The Messi-nevitable: Inter Miami CF
No. 2 seed in the East
Record: 16W 6L 12D
Points vs. xPoints: 60 to 54.5
Goals vs. xGoals: 80 to 72.4
Goals Against vs. xGoals Against: 59 vs. 59.3
At the risk of sounding insufferable: Lionel Messi.
Messi is poised to win his third straight MVP award, having mounted a 26-goal, 17-assist campaign, which accounts for more than half of IMCF's impressive 80-goal output in 2026. They're defensively suspect and built weirdly, but as long as Messi's involved ... well, you saw this summer's World Cup final. As long as Messi's on the field, there's a chance for him to pop up somewhere unexpected and do something transcendental. Even if it doesn't happen, the threat of that permeates whatever match he's playing.
Miami's path to get to the final is a little tricky: Getting past Columbus in the first round should be achievable, setting up for a matchup against the winner of No. 3 New England vs. No. 6 Philadelphia, which we'll get to shortly. Then, unless something strange happens, Nashville would stand in the way of a return to MLS Cup.
Oh, also, don't forget: the Herons are the reigning champions. I don't think they'll repeat ultimately, as that's hard to do, and hasn't been done since the Galaxy did it in 2011-12. But it's hard to kill zombies, and Messi teams tend to be zombies in the soccer sense.
The historically great: Nashville SC
No. 1 seed in the East, Supporters' Shield winners
Record: 23W 3L 8D
Points vs. xPoints: 77 to 54.1
Goals vs. xGoals: 71 to 59.7
Goals Against vs. xGoals Against: 25 vs. 46.5
The Yotes broke the single-season points record in 2026 en route to winning the Supporters' Shield, going undefeated at home, but what's really impressive is just how significantly they outperformed their underlying numbers. Per ASA's metrics, Nashville was a 54-point team with a goal differential of 6, which would make them a respectable six-seed.
Instead, they have an absurd goal differential of 46, coupling a healthy offensive output with one of the stingiest defenses in MLS history. Brian Schwake is almost certain to win MLS Goalkeeper of the year, and Maxwell Woledzi already won Defender of the Year from a field that was entirely made up of Nashville defenders.
The one caveat I keep coming back to is that only one Supporters' Shield winner in the last eight years has won MLS Cup — 2022 LAFC, who needed a Gareth Bale stoppage-time miracle and then Ilie Sánchez making the smart choice in the kicks-from-the-spot sequence to do it. Before that, it was a generationally good 2017 Toronto FC pulling it off. Nashville is just the team that can do it, of course. It just doesn't happen very often.
The road leading to the conference final should be pretty straightforward, but their last two matches could prove challenging. And, thankfully for us, fun to watch.
The eminently fun: Vancouver Whitecaps FC
No. 1 seed in the West
Record: 19W 8L 7D
Points vs. xPoints: 64 to 64.4
Goals vs. xGoals: 74 to 74.2
Goals Against vs. xGoals Against: 34 vs. 43.9
Thomas Müller has an absurd soccer resume. World Cup winner (and very nearly a World Cup Golden Boot winner), Champions League winner, tons of domestic titles and cup wins with Bayern Munich. Could he — now that he's finally rounding into health after a hamstring injury that's kept him sidelined the last month – add an MLS Cup to the trophy case?
As Austin fans saw in an improbable road win and a more predictable home loss, Vancouver's an electric team that moves the ball well and finds attackers in dangerous areas routinely. Their goals and xGoals numbers are nearly identical and among the league's best, and their defense performs better than expected.
The caveat with Vancouver is they haven't been the same since moving Sebastian Berhalter to Middlesbrough midseason. That exit did coincide with Ryan Gauld fully getting back into the fold after a year and change in the injury wilderness, and Oliver Larraz has been Berhalter adjacent with some of his performances, but more than one pundit projects they'll fall just short.
I have them winning it all, but part of that is hope borne of my half-Canadian heritage, part of that is wanting the 'Caps to stay in Vancouver, and part of that is just enjoying watching them play and wanting them to do that for as long as possible. (The tail end of their rolling NPxGD is a bit concerning if you're banking on them winning.)
The Open Cup holders: St. Louis City SC
No. 3 seed in the West
Record: 15W 10L 9D
Points vs. xPoints: 54 to 53.2
Goals vs. xGoals: 59 to 58.4
Goals Against vs. xGoals Against: 48 vs. 50.6
St. Louis had a 21-match unbeaten streak that started after Austin FC beat them in an early May match in Q2 Stadium, and won a grueling U.S. Open Cup final in the midst of a slight late-season swoon once that unbeaten streak fell in a loss to the Loons.
In 2025, City only mustered 32 points and finished 13th in the West. Even with midseason exits for two pillars of the club, Marcel Hartel and Eduard Löwen, St. Louis kept the impressive win streak going, bringing in Rafael Navarro from Colorado to keep the offense functioning, and finished 22 points better, which is akin to Austin's 2021 to 2022 transformation.
What might keep St. Louis from advancing to MLS Cup is the competition in the West. Its first round is against LAFC, which has been inconsistent this season, but still has Denis Bouanga and Son Heung-min, plus some new additions allowing them to play its high-octane style. (Hold that thought.)
The second round likely comes against FC Dallas (though Portland will have something to say about that, being on a four-match win streak), and then the conference final likely comes against Vancouver. That's a gauntlet that I don't think St. Louis will survive, though I do think they'll give the Whitecaps quite the fight in the conference final.
The comeback kids: Philadelphia Union
No. 6 seed in the East
Record: 14W 12L 8D
Points vs. xPoints: 50 to 53.2
Goals vs. xGoals: 59 to 58.4
Goals Against vs. xGoals Against: 48 vs. 50.6
The Union aren't like other MLS playoff six seeds. They started the season getting just seven points from their first 15 matches, fired Bradley Carnell, installed Ryan Richter as interim head coach, and then went on a 2.26 PPG tear the rest of the season, which is the exact level Nashville played at during its epic season-long run. The rolling NPxGD chart shows the stark difference in the two halves of the season; imagine where the Union would be if they decided to stick with Carnell. (Imagine where St. Louis would be as well, who also jettisoned Carnell in its brief history.)
Provided the Union get past the Revolution in the first round, this sets up for a matchup with Miami that could be chaotic. Three days before Carnell was dismissed, the Union lost a 6-4 match in Miami that included Milan Iloski and Luis Suarez hat tricks. In the August rematch with the newly constituted Union in Chester, the teams drew 2-2, with Cavan Sullivan and Yannick Bright getting red cards in the 12th minute of second-half stoppage time.
All I want for Christmas is a Miami vs. Philly playoff matchup. Oh, and to be greedy, a Nashville vs. Philly conference final.
The Hollywood stars: LAFC
No. 6 seed in the West
Record: 12W 11L 11D
Points vs. xPoints: 47 to 55
Goals vs. xGoals: 52 to 59.8
Goals Against vs. xGoals Against: 40 vs. 46.8
=
To be clear, this is not a team that should, per metrics and even per the eye test, have a shot at making MLS Cup. There are better teams in the West, after all, and some of those match up on the field favorably to them.
But when you have Son Heung-min and Denis Bouanga on your squad, you're not out of it until you're officially eliminated.
Granted, that could happen to LAFC in the first round, given that they're playing St. Louis, who did beat them in May after LAFC won in March to split the season series.
But look at that rolling NPxGD in the last part of the season. It didn't quite translate to results down the stretch — they went 1w 2L 3D in their last six, with the only win coming against Austin, but they also had to face a Minnesota and a Seattle desperate to get into the playoffs in their final two matches. (One did, one didn't.)
Interim head coach Xavi Tamarit is integrating some new role players into the squad, namely Leo Walta (on loan from Swansea) and Armindo Sieb (from Bayern Munich), currently wearing the No. 9 jersey. But in the end, you know what this comes down to.
Verde All Day is a reader-supported online publication covering Austin FC. Additional support is provided by Austin Telco Federal Credit Union. For more coverage, check out Emergency Podcast! (an Austin FC Podcast) wherever you get your podcasts, and join us on Instagram to get updates on all our stories and podcast releases.
Brad Stuver is a Humanitarian of the Year finalist for the fourth time. We review his chances as part of a who will win/who should win look at MLS award finalists.
Austin FC announced its first three player exits on Tuesday, including the club's current captain and a three-year starter who helped anchor the defense. The club said it would announce more roster moves later.
Davy Arnaud will be staying on as an Austin FC assistant coach following his stint as interim head coach. Meanwhile, two players have gone to Instagram to tell fans they're leaving the club.
Austin FC lost its season finale on Saturday, and while one player is already looking to a future with Jim Curtin, one gave a statement that had a certain air of finality to it.
Technically, 18 teams have a shot at winning MLS Cup in 2026, with the journey starting on Thursday for the four teams that squeaked into the play-in matches, and with others entering the fray on Saturday.
As I see it, six are mostly likely to triumph in the 2026 MLS playoffs, and curiously, Austin FC has played them all this season. MLS is truly a place where anything can happen in the playoffs — you'll recall that just two years ago, the Red Bulls emerged from the 7th spot in the East, with doubts late in that season that they'd even keep their long playoff appearance streak going, yet they found their way to the final.
To be fair, we have No. 6 seeds as two of our options — but they're highly unusual six-seeds.
Let's dig in.
The Messi-nevitable: Inter Miami CF
No. 2 seed in the East
Record: 16W 6L 12D
Points vs. xPoints: 60 to 54.5
Goals vs. xGoals: 80 to 72.4
Goals Against vs. xGoals Against: 59 vs. 59.3
At the risk of sounding insufferable: Lionel Messi.
Messi is poised to win his third straight MVP award, having mounted a 26-goal, 17-assist campaign, which accounts for more than half of IMCF's impressive 80-goal output in 2026. They're defensively suspect and built weirdly, but as long as Messi's involved ... well, you saw this summer's World Cup final. As long as Messi's on the field, there's a chance for him to pop up somewhere unexpected and do something transcendental. Even if it doesn't happen, the threat of that permeates whatever match he's playing.
Miami's path to get to the final is a little tricky: Getting past Columbus in the first round should be achievable, setting up for a matchup against the winner of No. 3 New England vs. No. 6 Philadelphia, which we'll get to shortly. Then, unless something strange happens, Nashville would stand in the way of a return to MLS Cup.
Oh, also, don't forget: the Herons are the reigning champions. I don't think they'll repeat ultimately, as that's hard to do, and hasn't been done since the Galaxy did it in 2011-12. But it's hard to kill zombies, and Messi teams tend to be zombies in the soccer sense.
The historically great: Nashville SC
No. 1 seed in the East, Supporters' Shield winners
Record: 23W 3L 8D
Points vs. xPoints: 77 to 54.1
Goals vs. xGoals: 71 to 59.7
Goals Against vs. xGoals Against: 25 vs. 46.5
The Yotes broke the single-season points record in 2026 en route to winning the Supporters' Shield, going undefeated at home, but what's really impressive is just how significantly they outperformed their underlying numbers. Per ASA's metrics, Nashville was a 54-point team with a goal differential of 6, which would make them a respectable six-seed.
Instead, they have an absurd goal differential of 46, coupling a healthy offensive output with one of the stingiest defenses in MLS history. Brian Schwake is almost certain to win MLS Goalkeeper of the year, and Maxwell Woledzi already won Defender of the Year from a field that was entirely made up of Nashville defenders.
The one caveat I keep coming back to is that only one Supporters' Shield winner in the last eight years has won MLS Cup — 2022 LAFC, who needed a Gareth Bale stoppage-time miracle and then Ilie Sánchez making the smart choice in the kicks-from-the-spot sequence to do it. Before that, it was a generationally good 2017 Toronto FC pulling it off. Nashville is just the team that can do it, of course. It just doesn't happen very often.
The road leading to the conference final should be pretty straightforward, but their last two matches could prove challenging. And, thankfully for us, fun to watch.
The eminently fun: Vancouver Whitecaps FC
No. 1 seed in the West
Record: 19W 8L 7D
Points vs. xPoints: 64 to 64.4
Goals vs. xGoals: 74 to 74.2
Goals Against vs. xGoals Against: 34 vs. 43.9
Thomas Müller has an absurd soccer resume. World Cup winner (and very nearly a World Cup Golden Boot winner), Champions League winner, tons of domestic titles and cup wins with Bayern Munich. Could he — now that he's finally rounding into health after a hamstring injury that's kept him sidelined the last month – add an MLS Cup to the trophy case?
As Austin fans saw in an improbable road win and a more predictable home loss, Vancouver's an electric team that moves the ball well and finds attackers in dangerous areas routinely. Their goals and xGoals numbers are nearly identical and among the league's best, and their defense performs better than expected.
The caveat with Vancouver is they haven't been the same since moving Sebastian Berhalter to Middlesbrough midseason. That exit did coincide with Ryan Gauld fully getting back into the fold after a year and change in the injury wilderness, and Oliver Larraz has been Berhalter adjacent with some of his performances, but more than one pundit projects they'll fall just short.
I have them winning it all, but part of that is hope borne of my half-Canadian heritage, part of that is wanting the 'Caps to stay in Vancouver, and part of that is just enjoying watching them play and wanting them to do that for as long as possible. (The tail end of their rolling NPxGD is a bit concerning if you're banking on them winning.)
The Open Cup holders: St. Louis City SC
No. 3 seed in the West
Record: 15W 10L 9D
Points vs. xPoints: 54 to 53.2
Goals vs. xGoals: 59 to 58.4
Goals Against vs. xGoals Against: 48 vs. 50.6
St. Louis had a 21-match unbeaten streak that started after Austin FC beat them in an early May match in Q2 Stadium, and won a grueling U.S. Open Cup final in the midst of a slight late-season swoon once that unbeaten streak fell in a loss to the Loons.
In 2025, City only mustered 32 points and finished 13th in the West. Even with midseason exits for two pillars of the club, Marcel Hartel and Eduard Löwen, St. Louis kept the impressive win streak going, bringing in Rafael Navarro from Colorado to keep the offense functioning, and finished 22 points better, which is akin to Austin's 2021 to 2022 transformation.
What might keep St. Louis from advancing to MLS Cup is the competition in the West. Its first round is against LAFC, which has been inconsistent this season, but still has Denis Bouanga and Son Heung-min, plus some new additions allowing them to play its high-octane style. (Hold that thought.)
The second round likely comes against FC Dallas (though Portland will have something to say about that, being on a four-match win streak), and then the conference final likely comes against Vancouver. That's a gauntlet that I don't think St. Louis will survive, though I do think they'll give the Whitecaps quite the fight in the conference final.
The comeback kids: Philadelphia Union
No. 6 seed in the East
Record: 14W 12L 8D
Points vs. xPoints: 50 to 53.2
Goals vs. xGoals: 59 to 58.4
Goals Against vs. xGoals Against: 48 vs. 50.6
The Union aren't like other MLS playoff six seeds. They started the season getting just seven points from their first 15 matches, fired Bradley Carnell, installed Ryan Richter as interim head coach, and then went on a 2.26 PPG tear the rest of the season, which is the exact level Nashville played at during its epic season-long run. The rolling NPxGD chart shows the stark difference in the two halves of the season; imagine where the Union would be if they decided to stick with Carnell. (Imagine where St. Louis would be as well, who also jettisoned Carnell in its brief history.)
Provided the Union get past the Revolution in the first round, this sets up for a matchup with Miami that could be chaotic. Three days before Carnell was dismissed, the Union lost a 6-4 match in Miami that included Milan Iloski and Luis Suarez hat tricks. In the August rematch with the newly constituted Union in Chester, the teams drew 2-2, with Cavan Sullivan and Yannick Bright getting red cards in the 12th minute of second-half stoppage time.
All I want for Christmas is a Miami vs. Philly playoff matchup. Oh, and to be greedy, a Nashville vs. Philly conference final.
The Hollywood stars: LAFC
No. 6 seed in the West
Record: 12W 11L 11D
Points vs. xPoints: 47 to 55
Goals vs. xGoals: 52 to 59.8
Goals Against vs. xGoals Against: 40 vs. 46.8
To be clear, this is not a team that should, per metrics and even per the eye test, have a shot at making MLS Cup. There are better teams in the West, after all, and some of those match up on the field favorably to them.
But when you have Son Heung-min and Denis Bouanga on your squad, you're not out of it until you're officially eliminated.
Granted, that could happen to LAFC in the first round, given that they're playing St. Louis, who did beat them in May after LAFC won in March to split the season series.
But look at that rolling NPxGD in the last part of the season. It didn't quite translate to results down the stretch — they went 1w 2L 3D in their last six, with the only win coming against Austin, but they also had to face a Minnesota and a Seattle desperate to get into the playoffs in their final two matches. (One did, one didn't.)
Interim head coach Xavi Tamarit is integrating some new role players into the squad, namely Leo Walta (on loan from Swansea) and Armindo Sieb (from Bayern Munich), currently wearing the No. 9 jersey. But in the end, you know what this comes down to.
Verde All Day is a reader-supported online publication covering Austin FC. Additional support is provided by Austin Telco Federal Credit Union. For more coverage, check out Emergency Podcast! (an Austin FC Podcast) wherever you get your podcasts, and join us on Instagram to get updates on all our stories and podcast releases.
Read Next
Will Brad Stuver finally win? A look at the MLS Year-End Award Finalists (including Humanitarian of the Year)
Brad Stuver is a Humanitarian of the Year finalist for the fourth time. We review his chances as part of a who will win/who should win look at MLS award finalists.
Austin FC announces three player exits, with possibly more to come
Austin FC announced its first three player exits on Tuesday, including the club's current captain and a three-year starter who helped anchor the defense. The club said it would announce more roster moves later.
Postseason Roundup, Day 1: Arnaud stays, other coaches leave, two players signal exits
Davy Arnaud will be staying on as an Austin FC assistant coach following his stint as interim head coach. Meanwhile, two players have gone to Instagram to tell fans they're leaving the club.
'We were us, we stuck to it, and we were brave': Assessing Austin FC's season-ending loss
Austin FC lost its season finale on Saturday, and while one player is already looking to a future with Jim Curtin, one gave a statement that had a certain air of finality to it.