Will Brad Stuver finally win? A look at the MLS Year-End Award Finalists (including Humanitarian of the Year)
Brad Stuver is a Humanitarian of the Year finalist for the fourth time. We review his chances as part of a who will win/who should win look at MLS award finalists.
The day after Decision Day, me and other media members, as well as MLS players and technical staffs for MLS clubs, engage in an annual ritual: Voting for the league's year-end awards, which starts with a vote for referee and assistant referee, with a dropdown menu holding three names each — and typically not that the names that I would have put there.
Working through the Microsoft form, you get the awards we're about to cover here and a considerably larger dropdown menu. For me, I come into the awards with a decent sense of where I'm going, with bursts of research to either confirm that or to go a surprising new last-minute direction.
What we've arrived at is a list of finalists, including a number of the people I voted for — people that may not actually get the award in question, but most certainly deserve to be finalists. Let's review who's up for this, projecting who will win but also opining as to who should win.
The winners will be revealed "throughout the Audi 2026 MLS Cup Playoffs," and Austin FC, by virtue of having Brad Stuver as a perennial Humanitarian of the Year Award candidate.
(I'm including the MLS description for the ones that aren't self-evident.)
Landon Donovan MLS MVP
Evander (FC Cincinnati)
Guilherme (Houston Dynamo FC)
Lionel Messi (Inter Miami CF)
Hany Mukhtar (Nashville SC)
Cavan Sullivan (Philadelphia Union)
Who will win: It's annoying and utterly predictable, but it'll be Lionel Messi winning back-to-back-to-back MVP awards. His resume this year is ridiculous: 26 goals and 17 assists in 31 appearances, and despite Inter Miami's flaws, he was largely responsible for getting his team to second in the East, with 60 points, and a league-high 80 goals scored. I don't like it either, but it's inevitable.
Who should win: Subscribing to the best player on the best team theory — especially in a year where the best team broke the MLS single-season points record and went undefeated at home — I voted for Hany Mukhtar knowing it was a vote just to get other names besides Messi's in the finalist group. While his season wasn't as statistically impressive as 2022, the year he beat Sebastián Driussi in that two-horse MVP race, he was central to everything Nashville SC did well on offense.
Sigi Schmid MLS Coach of the Year
B.J. Callaghan (Nashville SC)
Yoann Damet (St. Louis City SC)
Jesper Sørensen (Vancouver Whitecaps FC)
Who will win: When you're leading your team to the all-time single-season MLS points record, it's a good bet that you'll win this award. It's true that B.J. Callaghan benefited from adding Cristian Espinoza to an already potent lineup, but as Austin FC interim head coach Davy Arnaud said when I asked him who he thought would win MLS Cup in his last midweek press conference, he said, "Seeing them up close and what they did, the way that they played here, that was probably the one game I'd say that you played where you felt like, man, this might be the best team in the league."
He added that whoever came out of the West — very possibly one of the two teams coached by the other finalists on this list — "They're going to have a tough, tough night against Nashville."
Who should win: While I think it's Callaghan, Yoann Damet oversaw the most impressive turnaround from where a team was in 2025 to where a team got to in 2026. Arnaud also praised St. Louis for having "really clear ideas about how they want to play," which absolutely speaks to coaching.
MLS Newcomer of the Year
Antoine Griezmann (Orlando City)
Guilherme (Houston Dynamo FC)
André Luiz (Sporting Kansas City)
Let's begin by laughing at MLS' qualification for this award: "Newcomer" is defined as a player with previous professional experience who made his MLS debut in 2026.
Who will win:Antoine Griezmann, a fresh new face in the MLS game who (booting up Wikipedia) started his career in 2009 and has more than 800 club appearances with more than 300 goals, plus 137 caps for France. He won a World Cup with Les Blues in 2018 and his team came up one PK sequence short from repeating in 2022. But, yes, newcomer. (Though 14 goals and eight assists in 18 games over a half-season is impressive, especially for an Orlando team that got into the playoffs despite giving up 78 goals in a season — which usually gets a team the Wooden Spoon.)
Who should win: It will pain you to hear this, but Guilherme is a more conventional newcomer, in that he was a relative unknown in the States before landing with the Dynamo, and put up 16 goals and 10 assists to lead them to a fifth in the West finish. It's even more impressive when you consider Houston only had 43 goals all season, meaning his goal contributions accounted for more than 60% of them.
MLS Young Player of the Year
Given to the best young player during the 2026 MLS regular season. Eligible players must be born on or after Jan. 1, 2004.
Julian Hall (Red Bull New York)
Adri Mehmeti (Red Bull New York)
Cavan Sullivan (Philadelphia Union)
Who will win: Julian Hall looked like an early candidate for this, jumping out to an early lead in the Golden Boot race and finishing with 13 goals and five assists. But then over in Philadelphia, Bradley Carnell was fired after a dismal first half of the season in which the Wooden Spoon looked imminent, Ryan Richter took over as interim head coach, and decided to play Cavan Sullivan, who finished the season with nine goals, 14 assists, and a bright USMNT future opening up.
Who should win: Sullivan's deserving, and since he's going to Man City in January 2028 — though who knows what Man City will be by that time, so stay tuned – we get just another calendar year to enjoy him in MLS.
MLS Defender of the Year
Andy Najar (Nashville SC)
Jeisson Palacios (Nashville SC)
Maxwell Woledzi (Nashville SC)
Who will win: Based on what I've seen in various pundit ballots, Maxwell Woledzi is the consensus choice. It's telling that all three finalists are from Nashville. That's quite unusual.
Who should win: While Woledzi is deserving, I took a flyer on the Union's Neil Pierre, who is the best defender I saw all year, and that includes all the Nashville candidates. If Pierre stays in MLS, which is a big if, I expect him to eventually get this award. We are doing these awards for the 2027 sprint season, right?
MLS Goalkeeper of the Year
Roman Bürki (St. Louis City SC)
Brian Schwake (Nashville SC)
Matt Turner (New England Revolution)
Who will win: Though there might be some momentum and love for Matt Turner, Brian Schwake has been consistent for a team that only gave up 25 goals all season, which is league lowest for goals allowed.
Who should win: I really can't see anyone other than Schwake winning this. I don't imagine the total votes are close.
MLS Comeback Player of the Year
Honors an MLS player who has overcome a severe injury and/or adversity, and as a result missed a significant portion of the 2025 season, and shown improved performance to achieve success during the 2026 MLS regular season.
Ryan Gauld (Vancouver Whitecaps FC)
Nick Hagglund (FC Cincinnati)
Eduard Löwen (San Jose Earthquakes)
Who will win:Eduard Löwen had a compelling personal story, with his wife dying in March after a two-year battle with brain cancer. He also started the season with St. Louis and finished it with San Jose, getting a fresh start but also ending up with a much different team with much different leadership. This is usually an award given to a player who suffered a serious injury and returned, but Löwen's journey may prove compelling for the majority of the voters.
Who should win:Ryan Gauld has been through the injury wilderness. This is how the Whitecaps' PR staff put it, in timeline form:
October 23, 2024: Became the seventh player in league history to record a hat trick in the MLS Cup Playoffs
March 8, 2025: Suffered a left knee injury in the third match of the 2025 MLS regular season against CF Montréal, missing the majority of the season, and the entire first half of 2026
July 22, 2026: Made his first MLS start in 501 days, scoring at FC Cincinnati and becoming the first player in the club’s MLS era with 100 goal contributions across all competitions
He finished with 11 goal contributions in just over half a season, emerging as the team was transitioning from Sebastian Berhalter (who was moved to Middlesbrough) as its midfield anchor. Gauld was able to help the Whitecaps maintain their poise and finish first in the West.
MLS Humanitarian of the Year Award
Honors an MLS player who demonstrated outstanding dedication to charitable efforts and serving the community during the 2026 season.
Paul Arriola (Seattle Sounders FC)
Andrew Farrell (New England Revolution)
Telasco Segovia (Inter Miami CF)
Mason Stajduhar (Real Salt Lake)
Brad Stuver (Austin FC)
Who will win: I really want to put Brad Stuver here. Austin FC fans know how deserving he is. He was notably named as a finalist for the 2022 ESPN Muhammad Ali Sports Humanitarian Award at the ESPYs, the first MLS player to receive that honor, and he's now a four-time finalist. This should be the same sort of lifetime achievement award that his 2025 All-Star selection was.
But there's a complicating factor here: Andrew Farrell. The Revolution defender received his second MLS finalist nod this year, and is also retiring after 14 years of service. He's also got an impressive track record of work; per the Revs' PR team, "Farrell earned consideration for the leaguewide honor for his tireless commitment to service in 2026 and throughout his decorated career, the longest in club history. Farrell is particularly involved with Special Olympics Massachusetts, all childhood cancer initiatives, and the Revolution's C.H.A.N.G.E. social justice and equity platform."
Combine that range of work with respected veteran retiring, and I predict Farrell will get this in what will be a very gutwrenching vote for those who know and care.
Who should win: Stuver is continuing his career and will have other opportunities to win this award, even though he's moving into Susan Lucci territory. (Points to you if you get that reference. You'll crush at trivia if you did.) Personally, I think he should get this given that he's got multiple nominations and an impressive body of work, and would be thrilled if that happened. I just have a feeling that the other most deserving person in the field will get this.
Verde All Day is a reader-supported online publication covering Austin FC. Additional support is provided by Austin Telco Federal Credit Union. For more coverage, check out Emergency Podcast! (an Austin FC Podcast) wherever you get your podcasts, and join us on Instagram to get updates on all our stories and podcast releases.
Austin FC announced its first three player exits on Tuesday, including the club's current captain and a three-year starter who helped anchor the defense. The club said it would announce more roster moves later.
Davy Arnaud will be staying on as an Austin FC assistant coach following his stint as interim head coach. Meanwhile, two players have gone to Instagram to tell fans they're leaving the club.
Austin FC lost its season finale on Saturday, and while one player is already looking to a future with Jim Curtin, one gave a statement that had a certain air of finality to it.
Austin FC came into its final match of the 2026 season hoping for a home win. Instead, the Timbers got their winning goal, punching their playoff ticket, in the match's third minute.
The day after Decision Day, me and other media members, as well as MLS players and technical staffs for MLS clubs, engage in an annual ritual: Voting for the league's year-end awards, which starts with a vote for referee and assistant referee, with a dropdown menu holding three names each — and typically not that the names that I would have put there.
Working through the Microsoft form, you get the awards we're about to cover here and a considerably larger dropdown menu. For me, I come into the awards with a decent sense of where I'm going, with bursts of research to either confirm that or to go a surprising new last-minute direction.
What we've arrived at is a list of finalists, including a number of the people I voted for — people that may not actually get the award in question, but most certainly deserve to be finalists. Let's review who's up for this, projecting who will win but also opining as to who should win.
The winners will be revealed "throughout the Audi 2026 MLS Cup Playoffs," and Austin FC, by virtue of having Brad Stuver as a perennial Humanitarian of the Year Award candidate.
(I'm including the MLS description for the ones that aren't self-evident.)
Landon Donovan MLS MVP
Who will win: It's annoying and utterly predictable, but it'll be Lionel Messi winning back-to-back-to-back MVP awards. His resume this year is ridiculous: 26 goals and 17 assists in 31 appearances, and despite Inter Miami's flaws, he was largely responsible for getting his team to second in the East, with 60 points, and a league-high 80 goals scored. I don't like it either, but it's inevitable.
Who should win: Subscribing to the best player on the best team theory — especially in a year where the best team broke the MLS single-season points record and went undefeated at home — I voted for Hany Mukhtar knowing it was a vote just to get other names besides Messi's in the finalist group. While his season wasn't as statistically impressive as 2022, the year he beat Sebastián Driussi in that two-horse MVP race, he was central to everything Nashville SC did well on offense.
Sigi Schmid MLS Coach of the Year
Who will win: When you're leading your team to the all-time single-season MLS points record, it's a good bet that you'll win this award. It's true that B.J. Callaghan benefited from adding Cristian Espinoza to an already potent lineup, but as Austin FC interim head coach Davy Arnaud said when I asked him who he thought would win MLS Cup in his last midweek press conference, he said, "Seeing them up close and what they did, the way that they played here, that was probably the one game I'd say that you played where you felt like, man, this might be the best team in the league."
He added that whoever came out of the West — very possibly one of the two teams coached by the other finalists on this list — "They're going to have a tough, tough night against Nashville."
Who should win: While I think it's Callaghan, Yoann Damet oversaw the most impressive turnaround from where a team was in 2025 to where a team got to in 2026. Arnaud also praised St. Louis for having "really clear ideas about how they want to play," which absolutely speaks to coaching.
MLS Newcomer of the Year
Let's begin by laughing at MLS' qualification for this award: "Newcomer" is defined as a player with previous professional experience who made his MLS debut in 2026.
Who will win: Antoine Griezmann, a fresh new face in the MLS game who (booting up Wikipedia) started his career in 2009 and has more than 800 club appearances with more than 300 goals, plus 137 caps for France. He won a World Cup with Les Blues in 2018 and his team came up one PK sequence short from repeating in 2022. But, yes, newcomer. (Though 14 goals and eight assists in 18 games over a half-season is impressive, especially for an Orlando team that got into the playoffs despite giving up 78 goals in a season — which usually gets a team the Wooden Spoon.)
Who should win: It will pain you to hear this, but Guilherme is a more conventional newcomer, in that he was a relative unknown in the States before landing with the Dynamo, and put up 16 goals and 10 assists to lead them to a fifth in the West finish. It's even more impressive when you consider Houston only had 43 goals all season, meaning his goal contributions accounted for more than 60% of them.
MLS Young Player of the Year
Given to the best young player during the 2026 MLS regular season. Eligible players must be born on or after Jan. 1, 2004.
Who will win: Julian Hall looked like an early candidate for this, jumping out to an early lead in the Golden Boot race and finishing with 13 goals and five assists. But then over in Philadelphia, Bradley Carnell was fired after a dismal first half of the season in which the Wooden Spoon looked imminent, Ryan Richter took over as interim head coach, and decided to play Cavan Sullivan, who finished the season with nine goals, 14 assists, and a bright USMNT future opening up.
Who should win: Sullivan's deserving, and since he's going to Man City in January 2028 — though who knows what Man City will be by that time, so stay tuned – we get just another calendar year to enjoy him in MLS.
MLS Defender of the Year
Who will win: Based on what I've seen in various pundit ballots, Maxwell Woledzi is the consensus choice. It's telling that all three finalists are from Nashville. That's quite unusual.
Who should win: While Woledzi is deserving, I took a flyer on the Union's Neil Pierre, who is the best defender I saw all year, and that includes all the Nashville candidates. If Pierre stays in MLS, which is a big if, I expect him to eventually get this award. We are doing these awards for the 2027 sprint season, right?
MLS Goalkeeper of the Year
Who will win: Though there might be some momentum and love for Matt Turner, Brian Schwake has been consistent for a team that only gave up 25 goals all season, which is league lowest for goals allowed.
Who should win: I really can't see anyone other than Schwake winning this. I don't imagine the total votes are close.
MLS Comeback Player of the Year
Honors an MLS player who has overcome a severe injury and/or adversity, and as a result missed a significant portion of the 2025 season, and shown improved performance to achieve success during the 2026 MLS regular season.
Who will win: Eduard Löwen had a compelling personal story, with his wife dying in March after a two-year battle with brain cancer. He also started the season with St. Louis and finished it with San Jose, getting a fresh start but also ending up with a much different team with much different leadership. This is usually an award given to a player who suffered a serious injury and returned, but Löwen's journey may prove compelling for the majority of the voters.
Who should win: Ryan Gauld has been through the injury wilderness. This is how the Whitecaps' PR staff put it, in timeline form:
He finished with 11 goal contributions in just over half a season, emerging as the team was transitioning from Sebastian Berhalter (who was moved to Middlesbrough) as its midfield anchor. Gauld was able to help the Whitecaps maintain their poise and finish first in the West.
MLS Humanitarian of the Year Award
Honors an MLS player who demonstrated outstanding dedication to charitable efforts and serving the community during the 2026 season.
Who will win: I really want to put Brad Stuver here. Austin FC fans know how deserving he is. He was notably named as a finalist for the 2022 ESPN Muhammad Ali Sports Humanitarian Award at the ESPYs, the first MLS player to receive that honor, and he's now a four-time finalist. This should be the same sort of lifetime achievement award that his 2025 All-Star selection was.
But there's a complicating factor here: Andrew Farrell. The Revolution defender received his second MLS finalist nod this year, and is also retiring after 14 years of service. He's also got an impressive track record of work; per the Revs' PR team, "Farrell earned consideration for the leaguewide honor for his tireless commitment to service in 2026 and throughout his decorated career, the longest in club history. Farrell is particularly involved with Special Olympics Massachusetts, all childhood cancer initiatives, and the Revolution's C.H.A.N.G.E. social justice and equity platform."
Combine that range of work with respected veteran retiring, and I predict Farrell will get this in what will be a very gutwrenching vote for those who know and care.
Who should win: Stuver is continuing his career and will have other opportunities to win this award, even though he's moving into Susan Lucci territory. (Points to you if you get that reference. You'll crush at trivia if you did.) Personally, I think he should get this given that he's got multiple nominations and an impressive body of work, and would be thrilled if that happened. I just have a feeling that the other most deserving person in the field will get this.
Verde All Day is a reader-supported online publication covering Austin FC. Additional support is provided by Austin Telco Federal Credit Union. For more coverage, check out Emergency Podcast! (an Austin FC Podcast) wherever you get your podcasts, and join us on Instagram to get updates on all our stories and podcast releases.
Read Next
Austin FC announces three player exits, with possibly more to come
Austin FC announced its first three player exits on Tuesday, including the club's current captain and a three-year starter who helped anchor the defense. The club said it would announce more roster moves later.
Postseason Roundup, Day 1: Arnaud stays, other coaches leave, two players signal exits
Davy Arnaud will be staying on as an Austin FC assistant coach following his stint as interim head coach. Meanwhile, two players have gone to Instagram to tell fans they're leaving the club.
'We were us, we stuck to it, and we were brave': Assessing Austin FC's season-ending loss
Austin FC lost its season finale on Saturday, and while one player is already looking to a future with Jim Curtin, one gave a statement that had a certain air of finality to it.
At the Whistle: Austin FC 0, Portland Timbers FC 2
Austin FC came into its final match of the 2026 season hoping for a home win. Instead, the Timbers got their winning goal, punching their playoff ticket, in the match's third minute.